I found it.
When I was a kid spending summers on the beach we were lucky to get ice cream pretty much every day when the ice cream man (or, just as often, woman) would ring their bell every 30-45 minutes or so. Sometimes it was a full lunch truck with hot dogs and snacks and ice cream, snow cones, etc.
But the rest of the time it was a bicycle with a freezer custom fashioned to the frame similar to this:
I remember a rotation of treats I’d get: WWF Superstars Ice Cream Bars, Choco Tacos, Chipwich, and the rainbow Sno Cones. But the thing I got more than all those was a Superstar Fudge. These banana-chocolate fudgsicles were unique to the ice cream man. They weren’t sold in stores and I could only get them during the summer from an ice cream bike or truck.
As beach visits ended for me so did my Superstar Fudge indulgences. Over the last 15 or so years I’d look for them and occasionally an ice cream truck would have a cheap knockoff, but I could find no record of the Superstar Fudge or it’s red, white and blue ice pop partner the Superstar Ice. I began to think I’d imagined the name.
So I was delighted when one of my periodic searches turned up an ice cream truck sticker – the same sticker that adorned those trucks and bicycles that sold me my childhood treat. So, because the internet was lacking in proof the Superstar Fudge existed – here it is.
I have no idea when they went away. A knockoff about half the size is sold by Blue Bunny today under the “Bomb Pop” line of popsicles. It tastes similar but of course it’s a “frozen confection”, not ice cream, as ice cream makers cheapen up the products wherever they can get away with it (have you tasted how awful Breyer’s is anymore? It’s a shell of it’s former all natural self).
Have a great summer.
I don’t know if you are still looking but I believe your ice cream treat was starts by Rich’s ice cream out of Florida: https://www.richicecream.com/article/richs_retro_goodies#
Notice the retro treats include Super Star
Can you order this ice cream pop?